How to Review AI Coding Assistant Suggestions Before You Commit Them
A practical checklist for developers using Copilot, ChatGPT, Claude, Cursor or other AI assistants — how to catch invented APIs, hidden edge-case bugs, security holes, outdated patterns and overconfident explanations before they reach your codebase.
By Software Side Hustles Editorial Team · Published · Updated · 5 min read
Quick answer: treat AI-generated code like a pull request from a fast, confident colleague who has never seen your codebase. Before committing, check that it does what you asked (not just what it says it does), that every API and package it uses exists, that it handles edge cases and untrusted input, that it fits your conventions and versions, and that you have run it — ideally with a test that would fail if it were wrong.
Why AI suggestions need a different kind of review
AI assistants produce code that is fluent, well formatted and plausible. That is exactly what makes their mistakes easy to miss: the usual signals of sloppy code — odd naming, inconsistent style — are absent. The errors are in the substance: an edge case, a wrong assumption about your data, a function that does not exist in your library version.
The good news is that the failure modes are predictable. Use the checklist below.
The checklist
1. Does it solve the problem you actually asked?
Reread your prompt, then the code. Look for silently dropped requirements: "preserve the original order", "don't modify the input", "without external libraries", "at most five concurrent requests". Assistants frequently satisfy the main request and ignore a constraint. Our guide on evaluating AI-generated code shows this with a worked example.
2. Do all the APIs, options and packages exist?
Models sometimes invent plausible functions, method parameters, configuration keys or entire packages. Before trusting a call you have not seen before:
- Check the official documentation for your version.
- Confirm a suggested dependency exists on the registry, is the package you think it is (check the publisher, download counts and repository), and is maintained. Attackers register package names that assistants are likely to hallucinate — sometimes called "slopsquatting" — so a non-existent name is a security risk, not just a build error.
- Prefer the standard library or dependencies you already have over new ones.
3. Is it current for your stack?
Training data includes years of older code. Watch for deprecated APIs (datetime.utcnow(), React class components where you use hooks, old Node.js callback APIs), patterns from previous major versions of your framework, and security advice that has since changed.
4. Trace it with real inputs, including the awkward ones
Pick concrete inputs and follow them through: an empty list, one element, duplicates, null/None, a very large value, Unicode text, a different time zone. Most AI bugs live here — [10, 9, 1].sort() in JavaScript, list(set(items)) losing order, round(2.675, 2), off-by-one boundaries. Our unit testing guide has a reusable edge-case checklist.
5. Look for security problems
Check every place where outside data enters:
- SQL built with string formatting instead of parameters. See preventing SQL injection.
- Shell commands built from strings (
shell=True,execwith interpolation). - Unescaped output into HTML (
innerHTML,dangerouslySetInnerHTML). - Secrets hard-coded "for the example", or logged in debug output.
- Overly permissive settings presented as fixes:
Access-Control-Allow-Origin: *with credentials, disabled TLS verification,chmod 777. See fixing CORS errors properly. - Missing authorisation checks — the code verifies a user is logged in, but not that they own the record.
6. Check error handling and failure paths
Does it catch exceptions only to ignore them? Does fetch code check res.ok? Are timeouts set on network calls? Does it clean up files, connections and locks? Does a failure halfway through leave data inconsistent?
7. Check complexity and performance claims
If the explanation says "O(n)" or "this is faster", verify it. Look for hidden linear operations inside loops and N+1 database queries. If the assistant says threads will speed up CPU-bound Python, be sceptical. See Big O notation explained and concurrency vs parallelism.
8. Does it fit your codebase?
Matching your conventions matters for the next person who reads it: existing helpers instead of reimplemented ones, the project's error-handling pattern, naming, logging and test style. AI code that duplicates a utility you already have is a maintenance cost even when it is correct.
9. Verify the explanation, not just the code
Explanations can be confidently wrong in ways the code is not, or describe behaviour the code does not have ("this handles empty input" when it does not). If you will paste the explanation into a pull request description or documentation, check each claim.
10. Run it — and add a test
Code you have not executed is a guess. Run it with the inputs from step 4. For anything non-trivial, write a test that fails without the change. If the assistant wrote the tests too, check they assert something meaningful — tests generated alongside the code can share its misunderstanding.
Prompting habits that reduce review effort
- State constraints explicitly: language and framework versions, "standard library only", performance limits, input sizes, error-handling expectations.
- Ask for edge cases and tests first, then the implementation.
- Ask it to list assumptions — the list often reveals the misunderstanding.
- Keep requests small. Reviewing a 20-line function is far more reliable than reviewing 400 lines at once.
- Ask for a critique of its own answer — then verify the critique too.
Red flags that deserve a closer look
| Red flag | Why |
|---|---|
| An API you have never seen | May not exist in your version — or at all |
| A new dependency for a small task | Supply-chain and maintenance cost |
Broad try/except or empty catch | Hides failures |
| "This is the most efficient way" | Often unverified |
| Security settings relaxed to make an error go away | Usually trades a visible error for an invisible vulnerability |
| Tests that only cover the happy path | Edge cases unverified |
Frequently asked questions
Is AI-generated code safe to use in production?
It can be, once it has passed the same review and testing as any other code. The risk is in skipping review because the code looks finished.
Who is responsible for AI-generated code?
You are — and your team's review process. The assistant is a tool, not an author with accountability.
Should I disclose that code was AI-assisted?
Follow your organisation's policy, and check licensing and confidentiality rules before pasting proprietary code into external tools.
Where this skill pays off
Everything on this checklist is exactly what professional AI evaluators do — except they are paid to do it, and their judgements help train the next generation of models. If you already review AI suggestions carefully, read how software engineers earn money training AI models, then test your eye in our free code review lab.